Just had a quick read through. I find it very strange that the 3BN and 3MB have the same length stroke. According the the haynes, as i think bradders stated before, the difference is 0.7m between the early dtr and tzr comared with the later dtr.
Someone said something about the altering of the exhaust port cause by this. If you stuck an extra gasket under the base then it would raise the height, which to me says that it would have the opposite affect to what someone said before about it giving more low end power. If the port is raised it would push it the other way. After all the powervalve lowers the height to give it more bottom end power.
I'll definityl have a look at the difference in size of the powervalve between 3mb and 3bn. I'd always assumed that the were the same.
I have a 4FU barrel at the moment and it appears to have th same head as the 4DL 33bhp model. I'm going to also compare it with a 3MB P markred barrel from a 4DL belgarda.
I would be very suprised if when making the 4DL belgarda, they used the inferior of the 2 barrels. They used a 3MB barrel and then did some porting work on it. I'll also have a look at the powervalve on that.
-- Edited by AndyYam on Tuesday 4th of December 2012 06:56:23 PM
Bradders, are the barrells in your photos measured from the bottom of the liner to the top of the casting, or Just the height top to bottom, of the outer casting?
The latter measurement is the important one, and all the 3BN barrells I've seen have a shorter outer casting than any 3MB barrells. Trying to replace a 3MB barrell with a 3BN one without changing the crank will (in my experience) always result in the piston hitting the head and locking the engine (using extra base gaskets may prevent this happening, but I wouldn't like to risk it!).
All left side crankcases from 1988 to 2007 are marked 3BN above the flywheel cover. There were few changes to the crankcases over this period so Yamaha presumably decided it wasn't worth updating the model code on them?
More confusingly, all powervalves fitted to 3MB barrells are also stamped 3BN! There are no powervalves with 3MB markings in existance as far as I know. However, these 3BN powervalves will not fit a 3BN barrell.
2RH is stamped on most, if not all genuine Yamaha conrods used with 3MB barrells. I'm not sure if the early (1988) models with 3BN barrells used shorter conrods, or had the crankpin fitted slightly more centrally in the flywheels to reduce the stroke.
i know wat ur sayin deetee bout the pv thing. I had 2 valves both with 3bn on them but one had the diffevent shape on the end for the servo but other wouldnt fit... y put the same ****ing code on it if it don't fit 3bn barrels??!!!.. yam really fuks me off with all these different codes for basically the same engine from 88-07 its a right head **** for no reason.
I didn't measure the barrels I jus compared the height side by side there is a difference but again more head ****. . three 3mb barrels.. with different y-# codes. one was different height... the one with a random "A" stamped on the skirt WTF? ? lol Iv given up tryin to workout there logic for all this mind buggery.
Yeah mate, I haven't worked out the differences between Y - 1, Y - 2, Y - 3 etc either.
I reckon the letter A is probably a red herring - anybody could have put that there.
The amount that the liner protrudes out the bottom of the barrell should also be irrelevant, as this won't effect the overall height of the barrell when it is fitted to the crankcases.
That barrel bradders sent me wont be going on until I have done a full engine rebuild. To be quite honest I'll probably buy a new bottom end to do it two just so I don't have to have the bike off the road. So long as the timing doesn't have to be changed then it should be an easy job to put that barrel on.
Might also be worth bearing in mind that the 1988 DTR's fitted with 3BN barrells had a red line on their tacho at 9,500 rpm, that's 1,000 rpm less than the 3MB model introduced the following year.
Some early Jap DTR's go way back to mid 80's I put this up showing the early models right up to the DTX's hopefully Seiki can make a section for it, it's in Pictures section at the minute.
What we are trying to determine is are the barrels.
So far we have produced no evidence to say that the barrels are since the bore diameter is actually bigger on the 3BN barrels. Since cc = Bore diameter X Stroke the connected rod MUST be shorter on the 3BN barrels. Therefore they are not interchangeable.
The 3BN head is actually restricted. Go to the first page to see how!
If you want a better ride then switch over to the less restricted 3MB head.
they wont change the rod length but the big end pin location on the crank its self. that determins stroke length, so if anything the cranks will be different, this is all bull**** tho y make it all different n complicated!??? lol
they wont change the rod length but the big end pin location on the crank its self. that determins stroke length, so if anything the cranks will be different, this is all bull**** tho y make it all different n complicated!??? lol
no matter how long or short the rod is it will still move the same distance, say the crank web is 5 inches in dia thats 2.5 inches from centerline of main journal and the centerline of the big end pin is 2 inches from that. the total distance traveled of the centerline of the big end pin is 4 inches from tdc to bdc.. what ever the rod length
Did We ever find out if the barrels are interchangeable ? i have both barrels (3bn y1 and a 3mb y1) and a spare 3bn bottom end will the 3bn cylinder work ?